Rajasthan High Court – Jodhpur
Laxman Lal vs Sawar Lal Verma, The Managing Director on 12 December, 2024
Author: Dinesh Mehta
Bench: Dinesh Mehta
[2024:RJ-JD:51285]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT
JODHPUR
S.B. Writ Contempt No. 1014/2017
in
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.813/2017
Dwarkesh Kumar S/o Meghraj Ji, R/o E-109, UIT Colony, Pratap
Nagar, Jodhpur.
—-Petitioner
Versus
1. Shri Kuldeep Ranka, Managing Director, Rajasthan State
Road Transport Corporation, Jaipur.
2. Shri Chandra Veer Singh Charan, Chief Manager,
Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation, Jodhpur.
—-Respondents
For Petitioner(s) : Mr. Pradeep Choudhary
Mr. Sukesh Bhati
Mr. Rajesh Shah
Mr. S.K.Verma
Ms. Mrinal Khatri
Mr. V.R. Choudhary
Mr. H.S. Shrimali
Mr. S.K.Poonia
Mr. Narendra Thanvi
Mr. Sushil Solanki
Mr. Uttam Singh Rajpurohit
Mr. Devanand Solanki
Mr. Bharat Devasi
Mr. Bhawani Singh
Mr. R.S. Saluja
Mr. Achraj Singh Saluja
Mr. Hari Singh Rajpurohit
Mr. Dinesh Purohit
Mr. Prakash Raika
Mr. Bhanwar Singh Deora
Mr. D.S. Soni
Mr. Mukesh Dave
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Harish Kumar Purohit
Mr. Shashank Sharma
Mr. Mahaveer Bishnoi, AAG
Mr. Suniel Purohit
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
[2024:RJ-JD:51285] (2 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017]
JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA
Order
12/12/2024
1. Present contempt petition so also other petitions enlisted in
the Schedule appended herewith which involve identical allegation
and facts are being disposed of conjointly by this Common order.
The Schedule shall be treated as part and parcel of the order
instant.
2. Learned counsel for the parties submits that the cases be
disposed of in terms of the order dated 10.12.2024 which this
Court has passed in S.B. Writ Contempt Petition No.1027/2018 :
Dungav Ram Vs. Shri Raj Hans Upadhyay & Ors.
3. The directions given in the case of Dungav Ram (supra) are
reproduced hereinbelow for the sake of convenience and clarity:-
“(i) All the retired employees [who had filed
their claims pursuant to order dated 07.05.2024
passed in the case of Dungav Ram (S.B. Writ
Contempt No. 1027/2018) or the order passed in
the case of Tara Chand Panchal (S.B. Writ
Contempt No. 1099/2019)] shall file their
objection(s)/claim(s) for determination of their
retiral dues and other benefits within a period of
two months.
(ii) The claims be filed in the office of the Chief
Manager of their respective depot (from which
depot the concerned employee has retired) in
two sets. It will be required of the Chief
Manager to give receipt of the claims so filed
with seal and date.
(iii) The Managing Director of the respondent –
Corporation shall within two months from today
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
[2024:RJ-JD:51285] (3 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017]
nominate one retired accountant or higher
official (Retd.) at each depot, to adjudicate the
claims so filed.
(iv) Such nominated retired employee shall
work as an ‘Arbitrator’.
(v) It will be required of the Chief Manager of
each Depot to provide a befitting place where
the Arbitrator can have his sitting/hearing.
(vi) All the claims filed by the employees shall
be sent to the Arbitrator, who shall fix the date
of hearing as per his convenience under
intimation to both the parties.
(vii) It will be required of the respondent –
Corporation to make entire service record of
each of the employees, whichever is necessary
for the purpose of determination of claim,
available to the Arbitrator.
(viii) An honorarium of Rs.500/- shall be paid by
each of the employees/claimants to the
Arbitrator, while the Corporation shall also pay
equal amount to him.
(ix) Out of the amount mentioned in clause
(viii) above, half of the amount (Rs.250/-) shall
be paid by both the parties to the Arbitrator at
the time of first hearing. The remaining amount
of (Rs.250/- each) shall be paid by the parties
immediately before the final award is passed by
the Arbitrator.
(x) The respondent – Corporation shall also be
free to file its objections regarding the claim so
lodged by the employees.
(xi) The Arbitrator shall take summary
proceedings and pass award indicating therein
the claim wise details of the amount payable.
(xii) With the consent of all the parties, it is
hereby ordered that the determination so made
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
[2024:RJ-JD:51285] (4 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017]
by the said Arbitrator shall be final and binding
on all the parties. No legal remedy against such
order shall be permissible to any party.
(xiii) Once the amount is determined by the
Arbitrator, it will be required of the respondent –
Corporation to pay the same on the basis of the
priority as given in the circular dated
03.11.2021 issued by the Corporation.
(xiv) Needless to mention that in case of a
deceased employee his wife or legal
representative shall be free to pursue the claim.
4. Notices of contempt are hereby discharged.
5. All the captioned contempt petitions stand disposed of with
same directions as has been given in the case of Dungav Ram
(supra).
(DINESH MEHTA),J
364-497 and 23, 26, 31, 126 and 135-akansha/Ajay-
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM) [2024:RJ-JD:51285] (5 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017] Schedule S.Nos. Item S.B. Writ Contempt Party Names Nos. Petition Nos. 1 364 1014/2017 Dwarkesh Kumar Vs. Kuldeep Ranka And Anr. 2 365 1250/2017 Chetan Prakash Soni Vs Kuldeep Ranka And Ors. 3 366 1327/2017 Shikander Khan Vs
Shailendra Agarwal And
Ors.
4 367 102/2018 Mohan Lal Limba Vs
Kuldeep Ranka And Anr.
5 368 737/2018 Ramesh Kumar Baweja Vs
Kuldeep Ranka And Anr.
6 369 753/2018 Moola Ram Nai Vs
Rsrtc And Ors
7 370 775/2018 Rajendra Pal Mata Vs
Kuldeep Ranka And Anr.
8 371 833/2018 Lrs Of Nand Lal Jain And
Ors. Vs
Shailendra Agrawal And
Ors.
9 372 842/2018 Bhanwar Lal Parihar Vs
Kuldeep Ranka And Anr.
10 373 874/2018 Ramkishore Vs
Kuldeep Ranka And Anr.
11 374 987/2018 Shiv Ratan Sharma Vs
Rajhans Upadhyaya
12 375 1010/2018 Ram Chandra Mali Vs
Sh. Raj Hans Upadhyay
13 376 1079/2018 Bhanwar Lal Khatik Vs
Rajesh Yadav
14 377 1084/2018 Laxman Lal Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
15 378 1131/2018 Anandi Lal Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
16 379 1163/2018 Ghanshyam Singh Rawal Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
17 380 1166/2018 Mahendra Singh Khichi Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
18 381 1174/2018 Laxman Singh Bhamu Vs
Sh. Sawar Lal Verma
19 382 1204/2018 Manna Ram Vs
Raj Hans Upadhayay
20 383 1207/2018 Bhanwar Lal Goswami Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
[2024:RJ-JD:51285] (6 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017]
21 384 1212/2018 Vijay Kumar Ranga Vs
Sh. Sawar Lal Verma
22 385 1216/2018 Dhan Bahadur Thapa Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
23 386 1217/2018 Jagmohan Singh Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
24 387 1243/2018 Jagdish Prasad Vs
Kuldeep Ranka
25 388 1323/2018 Abdul Majid Vs
Rajhans Upadhyaya
26 389 1324/2018 Khurshid Khan Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
27 390 1331/2018 Champa Lal Jat
Rajasthan State Transport
Corporation Vs
Kuldeep Ranka
28 391 1341/2018 Vikram Singh Rajpurohit Vs
Sh. Sanwar Mal
29 392 1344/2018 Jeevan Ram Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
30 393 1374/2018 Har Lal Kadela Vs
Shri Sanwar Mal Verma
31 394 1375/2018 Hanuman Sahay Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
32 395 1376/2018 Bheek Chand Vs
Shri Sanwar Mal Verma
33 396 1383/2018 Bhanwara Ram Panwar Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
34 397 1398/2018 Bhagwan Singh Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
35 398 1407/2018 Ashwini Kumar Parihar Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
36 399 1478/2018 Onkar Mal Jat Vs
Raj Hans Upadhyay
37 400 1513/2018 Om Prakash Sharma Vs
Shri Rajhans Upadhyaya
38 401 1516/2018 Ake Singh Ranawat Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
39 402 1532/2018 Girdhari Singh Vs
Kuldeep Ranka
40 403 1551/2018 Sajjan Singh Deora Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
41 404 1596/2018 Anwar Ali Vs
Sawarmal Verma
42 405 1616/2018 Ramniwas Choudhary Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
43 406 1617/2018 Kishore Singh Vs
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
[2024:RJ-JD:51285] (7 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017]
Sanwar Mal Verma
44 407 1675/2018 Gambhir Singh Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
45 408 1748/2018 Abdul Gafoor Vs
Shri Rajhans Upadhyay
46 409 1755/2018 Rameshwar Lal Ahir Vs
Shailendra Agrawal
47 410 1771/2018 Shrigopal Sharma Vs
Shailendra Agrawal
48 411 1780/2018 Raghunath Singh Vs
Rajhans Upadhyay
49 412 35/2019 Raghuvir Singh Chauhan Vs
Sawarmal Verma
50 413 44/2019 Jala Ram Vs
Raj Hans Upadhyay
51 414 45/2019 Manni Devi Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
52 415 48/2019 Basant Dave Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
53 416 67/2019 Chand Kishan Vs
Kuldeep Ranka
54 417 86/2019 Chunni Lal Vs
Shri Sawar Lal Verma
55 418 135/2019 Babu Khan Vs
Sawarmal Verma
56 419 189/2019 Ramesh Chandra Tailor Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
57 420 219/2019 Gajendra Singh Rao Vs
Sawar Mal Verma
58 421 220/2019 Harihar Singhq Vs
Shr Sawar Mal Verma,
59 422 222/2019 Bhagwati Lal Suthar Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
60 423 223/2019 Babu Lal Labana Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
61 424 224/2019 Khuman Singh Sisodia Vs
Sawar Mal Verma
62 425 228/2019 Kaushik Kumar Dave Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
63 426 252/2019 Durg Singh Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
64 427 260/2019 Hetu Dan Charan
State Of Rajasthan
65 428 280/2019 Dula Ram Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
66 429 287/2019 Smt. Prem Kanwar Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
[2024:RJ-JD:51285] (8 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017]
67 430 310/2019 Tulsi Ram Saini Vs
Rajhans Upadhyay
68 431 328/2019 Balwant Singh Vs
Suchi Sharma
69 432 332/2019 Radhey Shyam Purohit Vs
Suchi Sharma
70 433 372/2019 Topa Ram Vs
Miss. Shruti Sharma
71 434 376/2019 Maniram Beniwal Vs
Sh. Raj Hans Upadhaya
72 435 435/2019 Pukhraj Sain Vs
Shuchi Sharma
73 436 441/2019 Baldev Ram Vs
Raj Hans Upadhyay
74 437 442/2019 Shanti Devi Vs
Sanwar Mal Varma
75 438 450/2019 Devi Lal Patel Vs
Shri Rajhans Upadhyaya
76 439 465/2019 Hanuman Ram Vs
Raj Hans Upadhaya
77 440 474/2019 Lala Ram Vs
Sh. Sawar Lal Verma
78 441 526/2019 Mohd. Tasneem Khan Vs
Suchi Sharma
79 442 530/2019 Kana Ram Pandiya Vs
Sanwar Lal Verma
80 444 560/2019 Gopal Singh Rajpurohit Vs
Suchi Sharma
81 445 562/2019 Om Prakash Gehlot Vs
Suchi Sharma
82 446 572/2019 Nemi Chand Vs
Shruti Sharma
83 447 585/2019 Madan Singh Vs
Shuchi Sharma
84 448 662/2019 Gordhan Ram Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
85 449 665/2019 Ashok Kumar Chouhan Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
86 450 713/2019 Gaje Lal Vs
Sanwar Lal Verma
87 451 749/2019 Lal Singh Chauhan Vs
Sawar Mal Verma
88 452 766/2019 Arjun Singh Vs
Sanwar Mal Varma
89 453 793/2019 Kailash Kumar Saravgi Vs
Suchi Sharma
90 454 840/2019 Kishna Ram Vs
Shruti Sharma
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
[2024:RJ-JD:51285] (9 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017]
91 455 856/2019 Pukha Ram Vs
Rajhans Upadhyay
92 456 912/2019 Laxman Singh Chauhan Vs
Sawarmal Verma
93 457 927/2019 Kalyan Singh Vs
Ms. Suchi Sharma
94 458 928/2019 Mohan Lal Jyani Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
95 459 1015/2019 Sarafat Ali Vs
Sh. Alok Tripathi
96 460 1027/2019 Dinesh Chandra Bora Vs
Sawar Lal Verma
97 461 1076/2019 Sohan Lal Panwar Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
98 462 1098/2019 Lala Ram Patel Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
99 463 1117/2019 Madhav Lal Kumhar Vs
Ms Ratnu
100 464 1122/2019 Narendra Singh Chouhan Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
101 465 1132/2019 Madan Lal Kumawat Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
102 466 1133/2019 Okar Lal Menariya Vs
Sawarmal Verma
103 467 1134/2019 Pyar Chand Bilochi Vs
Sawarmal Verma
104 468 1138/2019 Kalu Khan Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
105 469 1140/2019 Amrit Lal Sharma Vs
Mr. Alok
106 470 1146/2019 Ghanshyam Das Vaishnava Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
107 471 1156/2019 Vijay Singh Ranawat Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
108 472 1157/2019 Ram Narayan Jat Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
109 473 1160/2019 Shoukat Hussain Vs
Ms Rathore
110 474 1167/2019 Bhanwar Singh Chauhan Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
111 475 1169/2019 Manohar Singh Shaktawat Vs
Sawarmal Verma
112 476 1170/2019 Himmat Singh Jhala Vs
Sawarmal Verma
113 477 1171/2019 Dev Kishan Acharya Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
114 478 1172/2019 Madan Singh Chauhan Vs
Sawarmal Verma
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
[2024:RJ-JD:51285] (10 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017]
115 479 1180/2019 Chandra Prakash Sharma Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
116 480 1243/2019 Hamid Khan Joya Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
117 481 1261/2019 Gumana Ram Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
118 482 1269/2019 Bhoor Singh Sisodia Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
119 483 1272/2019 Prem Chand Sharma Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
120 484 1281/2019 Anil Chaudhary Vs
Suchi Sharma
121 485 1283/2019 Shokat Ali Vs
Shri Alok
122 486 1284/2019 Hasti Mal Surana Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
123 487 48/2020 Chena Ram Choudhary Vs
Mr. Alok
124 488 50/2020 Mohan Singh Bhati Vs
Mr. Alok
125 489 51/2020 Amar Chand Kumawat Vs
Mr. Alok
126 490 57/2020 Shyam Lal Vs
Mr. Alok
127 491 60/2020 Devi Lal Ahir Vs
Sanwar Mal Verma
128 492 61/2020 Bhanwar Lal Bishnoi Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
129 493 62/2020 Harendra Singh Chouhan Vs
Suchi Sharma
130 494 65/2020 Omprakash Bairwa Vs
Mr. Alok
131 495 68/2020 Shanti Lal Lakhara Vs
Shri Sawar Mal Verma
132 496 72/2020 Krishna Kant Joshi Vs
Smt. Suchi Sharma
133 497 96/2020 Velji Gayari Vs
Suchi Sharma
134 26 729/2019 BABU KHAN Vs
SMT. SHUCHI SHARMA
135 31 325/2020 MUSTAK ALI Vs
ALOK
136 23 371/2019 MANGLA RAM Vs
SAWAR LAL VERMA
137 126 1678/2018 HANSRAJ Vs
KULDEEP RANKA
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
[2024:RJ-JD:51285] (11 of 11) [WCP-1014/2017]
138 135 621/2019 SURENDRA KUMAR Vs
SAWAR LAL VERMA
(Downloaded on 13/12/2024 at 11:27:34 PM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)